Mobile forensics tools for file carving: capability matrix

9 tools list carving as a function · Intro updated

File carving recovers files from raw data without relying on file system metadata. The NIST CFTT Forensic File Carving Tool Specification (draft version 1.0 for public comment, April 2014) defines carving tools as those that extract and reconstruct files without examination of file system metadata, identifying inaccessible deleted or embedded files from their data content. It explains that such tools use the data signatures of certain file types to identify starting and ending blocks, and that because file systems often keep file data blocks contiguous and sequential, finding the start and end may be enough to carve a complete file. Where blocks are non-contiguous or non-sequential, the specification says, reconstruction by carving is problematic.

NIST SP 800-101 Rev. 1 adds a mobile-specific limit: where iOS Data Protection is active, the file key is destroyed on deletion, which leaves encrypted contents in unallocated space and renders traditional carving of deleted files useless. The CFTT carving project page lists published test reports for graphic and video file carving tools. A tick in the matrix says an entry lists carving; it does not say which file types it carves or how it handles fragmented files.

At a glance

Tools9
By licenceCommercial: 3 · Open source: 6
By statusActive: 6 · Unmaintained: 2 · Status uncertain: 1
Targets listedAndroid: 4 of 9 · iOS: 4 of 9 · Windows: 4 of 9 · macOS: 3 of 9 · Linux: 3 of 9 · Drones: 1 of 9 · Wearables: 1 of 9 · IoT: 3 of 9 · Cloud services: 1 of 9 · Memory cards: 6 of 9 · Chip (NAND/eMMC/UFS): 1 of 9

Capability matrix

A tick reflects what the directory entry lists, not proof that the tool cannot do more. A dash means the entry does not list that target. Open an entry for the sourced detail.

Tools that list carving as a function, with the targets, licence and status each entry lists
ToolAndroidiOSWindowsmacOSLinuxDronesWearablesIoTCloud servicesMemory cardsChip (NAND/eMMC/UFS)LicenceStatus
AutopsyListed: AndroidListed: iOSListed: WindowsListed: macOSListed: LinuxNot listed: DronesNot listed: WearablesNot listed: IoTNot listed: Cloud servicesListed: Memory cardsNot listed: Chip (NAND/eMMC/UFS)Open sourceActive
BinwalkNot listed: AndroidNot listed: iOSNot listed: WindowsNot listed: macOSNot listed: LinuxNot listed: DronesNot listed: WearablesListed: IoTNot listed: Cloud servicesNot listed: Memory cardsNot listed: Chip (NAND/eMMC/UFS)Open sourceActive
bulk_extractorNot listed: AndroidNot listed: iOSNot listed: WindowsNot listed: macOSNot listed: LinuxNot listed: DronesNot listed: WearablesNot listed: IoTNot listed: Cloud servicesListed: Memory cardsNot listed: Chip (NAND/eMMC/UFS)Open sourceActive
ForemostNot listed: AndroidNot listed: iOSNot listed: WindowsNot listed: macOSNot listed: LinuxNot listed: DronesNot listed: WearablesNot listed: IoTNot listed: Cloud servicesListed: Memory cardsNot listed: Chip (NAND/eMMC/UFS)Open sourceUnmaintained
Forensic Toolkit for SQLiteListed: AndroidListed: iOSListed: WindowsNot listed: macOSNot listed: LinuxNot listed: DronesNot listed: WearablesListed: IoTNot listed: Cloud servicesNot listed: Memory cardsNot listed: Chip (NAND/eMMC/UFS)CommercialStatus uncertain
Paraben E3 Forensic PlatformListed: AndroidListed: iOSListed: WindowsListed: macOSListed: LinuxListed: DronesListed: WearablesListed: IoTListed: Cloud servicesNot listed: Memory cardsListed: Chip (NAND/eMMC/UFS)CommercialActive
PhotoRecListed: AndroidNot listed: iOSNot listed: WindowsNot listed: macOSNot listed: LinuxNot listed: DronesNot listed: WearablesNot listed: IoTNot listed: Cloud servicesListed: Memory cardsNot listed: Chip (NAND/eMMC/UFS)Open sourceActive
ScalpelNot listed: AndroidNot listed: iOSNot listed: WindowsNot listed: macOSNot listed: LinuxNot listed: DronesNot listed: WearablesNot listed: IoTNot listed: Cloud servicesListed: Memory cardsNot listed: Chip (NAND/eMMC/UFS)Open sourceUnmaintained
X-Ways ForensicsNot listed: AndroidListed: iOSListed: WindowsListed: macOSListed: LinuxNot listed: DronesNot listed: WearablesNot listed: IoTNot listed: Cloud servicesListed: Memory cardsNot listed: Chip (NAND/eMMC/UFS)CommercialActive

“Status uncertain” means the entry cannot currently confirm the tool’s availability or support; the reason is in the status note on that tool’s page.

Sources for the introduction

  1. NIST CFTT, Forensic File Carving Tool Specification (draft version 1.0 for public comment, April 2014)
  2. NIST SP 800-101 Rev. 1, Guidelines on Mobile Device Forensics (May 2014)
  3. NIST CFTT, Forensic File Carving project page

Other capabilities